Association of Commuter Rail Employees
                                               
 
 
 

February 3, 2010

Howard Permut, President

MTA/Metro North Railroad

 

Re: Seat Checking Procedures

Dear Howard,

The new seat checking and ticket collection process Ron Yee's group experimented with this past week was a terrible idea. It has already led to confrontation onboard train 1542, with passengers quite upset and insulted at being asked to show their tickets twice. We were advised this practice exists on the LIRR, however, it does so with the help of another class of employees (over 100 Ticket Punchers). That craft does not exist here at Metro North.

We fully understand the need to collect 100 percent of all revenue on board our trains. The revenue that seems to always be in jeopardy are intermediate fares. Our crews fully understand they should always be efficient when seat checking and patrolling their trains. But if Metro North is really serious about intermediate fare collection, then the only true resolution is adding the correct number of assistants to get the job done. Metro North has never staffed our trains to collect all intermediate fares. By the Planning Departments own admission and economic studies, it was not worth the expense of adding the required number of people to get the job done.

Hopefully, those who were in charge of this experiment will speak up and advise you of the terrible response it received and how unproductive it really was. It served no purpose other than to alienate our customers. Yesterday was a good indication of why we have higher customer satisfaction ratings and better revenue collection numbers than the LIRR and any other railroad for that matter.

Should you have any questions please don't hesitate to call my office.

Sincerely,

Anthony Bottalico

General Chairman


 
 

www.GoACRE.com